Posted November 30, 2007
Court: Abortion doc grand jury probe OK
By CARL
MANNING
Associated Press Writer
TOPEKA, Kan. - The Kansas Supreme Court has ruled
that a Sedgwick County grand jury investigation into a doctor who
performs late-term abortions can go forward.
The ruling, issued Thursday,
dismissed a petition filed last month by Dr. George Tiller, one of
the nation's few physicians who performs late-term abortions. He
challenged the legality of the grand jury proceedings.
The grand jury investigation in
Wichita, like one started in Johnson County looking into Planned
Parenthood of Kansas and Mid-Missouri, was created by a citizen
petition drive led by abortion foes.
Kansas is one of only six states that
permits citizens to petition to create a grand jury.
Abortion foes hailed the ruling.
Tiller's attorneys, Lee Thompson and Dan
Monnat, said in a statement issued Thursday that the
petition drive was politically motivated.
"It's been repeatedly determined that
Dr. Tiller is innocent of any wrongdoing and we just regret that
taxpayers' dollars are now going to have to be spent to enable this
grand jury to move forward," they said.
A Johnson County district judge on
Tuesday denied Planned Parenthood's request to block the start of
the panel, and the organization had planned to appeal. But Planned
Parenthood attorney Bob Eye said Friday that the clinic would not
appeal, saying the ruling issued in the Tiller case would likely
apply to its case.
"We respect the court's decision. We
think the similarities would have resulted in the same decision, and
we aren't here to waste the court's time," Eye said.
Impaneling a 15-member grand jury in
the Planned Parenthood case will begin Dec. 10 and it can meet for
up to 90 days, although that can be extended by the district court.
It takes 12 grand jurors to issue a recommendation.
Chief Judge Michael Corrigan in
Sedgwick County said he didn't know when the grand jury there will
begin its work.
Operation Rescue President Troy
Newman called Planned Parenthood's decision another victory on top
of the Supreme Court decision.
"We are celebrating these victories
today and are looking forward to seeing justice done, both in
Sedgwick and Johnson counties, through the grand jury process. We
finally have some hope that the system is beginning to function as
it should," Newman said in a statement.
Abortion opponents want the grand
jury to look into whether Planned Parenthood's Overland Park clinic
provided illegal late-term abortions. Eye said no late-term
abortions are done at the clinic and Planned Parenthood is innocent
of any wrongdoing.
Planned Parenthood already faces a
107-count criminal complaint filed by Johnson County District
Attorney Phill Kline in October. The complaint includes 29
misdemeanor counts of providing unlawful late-term abortions.
Kline, an anti-abortion Republican,
started investigating Planned Parenthood in 2003 when he was
attorney general. After a court battle, he eventually gained access
to some of the clinic's patient medical records.
Paul Morrison, an abortion-rights
Democrat who defeated Kline last year to become attorney general,
reviewed the records Kline obtained and found no wrongdoing by
Planned Parenthood.
However, Morrison filed 19
misdemeanor charges against Tiller in June, alleging Tiller failed
to get a second opinion on some late-term abortions from an
independent second physician, as required by law.
|