A Conversation with Dan Monnat
Sunday, November 29, 2009
CARRIE RENGERS
The Wichita Eagle
Trial lawyer Dan Monnat is well
known around Wichita, in part for his representation of high-profile
clients such as the late George Tiller. And
Monnat's firm, Monnat &
Spurrier, is close to celebrating its 25th anniversary.
But Monnat
also is known for being a drummer who appears regularly at C.
Major's Rockin' Daddy's. And his wife, Grace
Wu-Monnat, is a popular martial
arts teacher here who also works as
Monnat's office manager and trial consultant.
What did you want to be when you were
growing up?
"I thought it would be a great idea
to grow up and be the Lone Ranger."
But you became a lawyer instead. Any
Lone Ranger qualities there?
"Well, I like standing up for the
small person, the person who is different... the person who is
demonized or outcast."
You became a musician at age 13. How
did that impact you?
"As a young musician in the early
'60s, I got some sense that merely by being different in appearance,
such as by having long hair, you could be treated unfairly by some
school and legal authorities."
How so?
"I would get kicked out of school for
having long hair.
"When the police would come to
school... to ask about sniffing glue... they'd come get me because I
had long hair."
Did you ever want to be a musician
for a career?
"I always enjoyed writing both in
high school and as a musician.... I kind of wanted to find a way to
communicate that better to people."
So you went to San Francisco State
and got an English degree in creative writing. How did that
translate to a legal career?
"At some point, I was writing a story
about a character that I thought should be a lawyer.
"I learned that if you had good
grades, anyone could go to law school. I could go to law school. The
idea intrigued me."
So you went to law school at
Creighton?
"Yeah. My parents were flabbergasted.
"I enjoyed studying, and I enjoyed
communicating in person as a musician, and I thought, well, that
would be a great combination — the scholasticism of studying law in
your garret, if you will, and then going in the courtroom and
presenting it in person."
How did you decide to be a trial
lawyer?
"I really got interested in what they
call the moot court program, which is when you have a hypothetical
case and you get to argue it... as an appeal to a panel of judges."
And you were successful?
It "gave me for the first time the
actual thrill of the courtroom, so I always knew I wanted to be a
trial lawyer after that."
What's the best part of your job?
"The best part about the job is
representing people who you learn to understand, whose life you have
to communicate to juries. And the best part is when you learn that
jurors in America are everyday, independent, caring, responsible
people who will listen to the facts you bring them about your
client's life and make very fair, thoughtful decisions. And the most
impressive thing about the job is learning how much the average
American cares about their duty as a juror and how independent and
courageous they will be, frankly, in staring down the powers that be
with their verdicts day in and day out."
And the worst part?
"I could tell you that it's the long
hours. I could tell you that it was the people found not guilty
finding the money to pay your legal (fees). But probably the thing
that gnaws at me the most is that until they get in the jury box,
the American public does not realize... how many innocent people are
charged with crimes and forced to go to trial.
"It's actually shocking because until
we see otherwise, most of us believe in a romanticized, home-spun
yarn about our justice system. Namely that only guilty people are
pursued and convicted or that the justice system doesn't make
mistakes. The reality is that every day innocent people are
subjected to injustice, and they need somebody to fight for them."
And that's where you come in?
"I'm not some kind of wizard with
magical powers. I don't hypnotize the jurors into acquittals. My
clients are not acquitted by some kind of hocus-pocus of mine.
They're acquitted because they're innocent and the jurors can see
it."
Did you have any hesitation about
taking such a high-profile, controversial client as abortion
provider George Tiller?
"No hesitation at all. Because from
everything I knew, he was providing a service that women wanted and
women needed and that was absolutely protected by the Constitution.
As I got to know him and his practice better over the years, that
turned out to be 150 percent true."
And you knew the risks, including
possible physical injury to yourself?
"Particularly the day that Dr. Tiller
was shot. I knew that Grace was on the ladder trimming vines on the
house.... I jumped in the car and ran home and suggested she come
(inside) because no one knew what was going on."
What goals do you still want to
achieve in your career?
"Really, I'm pretty happy to have the
opportunity to get up and do a job that I love, whether that's
representing people in low-profile, mundane misdemeanor cases or
that's in high-profile felony cases."
Do you ever get disillusioned?
"You can't be a human being and not
be disillusioned by the fate of Dr. Tiller, but something like that
more indicates the necessity of criminal defense attorneys than it
does suggest giving up or going away."
Is music a release for you?
"Yes. You know, it's an opportunity
every week to change identities a little bit, and I love the
opportunity to play with the diverse array of musicians that show up
at C. Major's Rockin' Daddy's."
You met your wife through studying
martial arts. Since she's an expert, do you have to be careful
around her?
"Well, let me put that this way: Her
skills are so formidable that I know much better than to ever
challenge them. That probably means I've learned the first lesson of
Grace Wu martial arts principals, which is the most skilled martial
artist never ends up in a situation where she or he would have to
fight."
What's one thing no one knows about
you?
"That I've been officially declared
Grace Wu's most hopeless Chinese martial arts student."
|